NOW SPINNING

Twelve Lessons in Control

WORDS BY

POSTED

ROLL THE DICE. PRESS PLAY.

PRESS PLAY ↗

THE
DPP
FILE


WE LISTENED.
WE HAD THOUGHTS.
NOW YOU PRESS PLAY.

Rating: 8 out of 10.

Charlie Puth’s latest album, Whatever’s Clever! feels like Professor Puth is still cooking with his signature recipe of music writing, but this time adding more maturity. Across 12 tracks, he leans into a polished world of late-’80s and early-’90s pop, soft rock warmth, and R&B-leaning melodies. The sound is clear from the start: groovy, bright, clean, and almost aggressively comfortable.

That comfort is part of the album’s charm, though also part of its limitation. Nothing here fights for attention. The grooves stay steady, the harmonies are precise, and every choice feels carefully placed. Puth has always been known for control, but on this record, control becomes the whole environment. 

The features mostly follow that same rule. Kenny G, Ravyn Lenae, Hikaru Utada, and Coco Jones do not pull the album in new directions as much as they add different shades to its existing palette. Even Jeff Goldblum, who appears on Until It Happens To You, fits the retro-jazz idea on paper. In practice, though, his presence slightly breaks the emotional spell. It is a clever choice, but not necessarily the most affecting one.

He shows his skills of keeping the emotion tucked underneath the production, letting tone and melody carry what the lyrics often leave unsaid. That restraint works best in the middle of the record. Hey Brother and Sideways do not need to over-explain themselves. They are not especially dramatic or lyrically detailed, but they have a softness that lingers. They feel less like big emotional statements and more like quiet pauses in the album’s flow.

The sequencing also gives the record a subtle sense of self-awareness. Opening with Changes and closing with I Used to Be Cringe suggests a loose arc of growth, or at least a recognition of how Puth has been perceived. Still, the ending track sits a little outside the album’s sonic world. New Jersey, by contrast, fits the sound more naturally, though it feels lighter in weight, almost like a passing joke that works in the moment without leaving much behind.

The strongest songs are the ones where the polish leaves enough room for something human to slip through. Love In Exile, Home, and Washed Up find the album’s best balance: controlled but not closed off, smooth but not empty. Puth does not fully let the edges show, but he lets you sense that they are there.

Whatever’s Clever! sounds like one refining the space he already knows how to occupy. These 12 lessons are not really about surprise. They are about control — how much he can hold back, how much he can smooth over, and how much feeling can still survive underneath.


THE RECORD STOPS HERE.

NEXT SPIN →

Leave something on the record.

Leave a Reply

Discover more from DICE PRESS PLAY

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading